India won their first bilateral ODI series in Srilanka, it is heartening that this was achieved with an incomplete team - no Sachin and Sehwag. But if we look at the tour - what we actually did was won the toss 4 times in a row. Nothing to take away from excellent performance of Zaheer, Dhoni and company. But the results were rather sealed as soon as the toss happened- this should be agreed atleast for Premadasa.
This reminded me of some of other grounds where you more or less know whats going to happen as soon as the toss is done - atleast the match is not unbiassed anymore. Let us look at results of day-night matches from some of the grounds during various timeframes in the last decade and a half.
Ground | Time Period | Matches Played | Won batting first | Won batting second |
Newlands, Capetown | 1992-08 | 24 | 19 | 5 |
Premadasa, Colombo | 2000-08 | 40 | 26 | 11 |
Kingsmead, Durban | 2003-08 | 14 | 6 | 3 |
PCA,Mohali | 1996-07 | 14 | 9 | 5 |
Gaddafi, Lahore | 2007-08 | 8 | 8 | 0 |
Eden Gardens | 1993-03 | 9 | 7 | 2 |
These results are mainly affected by dew that either helps the bowlers get some swing under the lights and trouble the batsmen. When we have the data to support the argument that the toss plays a very important role in deciding the result of the match is it fair to still play under these conditions.
Of course there are some grounds where the results are just reverse as the weather is relatively dry and dew only results in spin bowlers not being able to find the grip of the ball under lights and the batsmen makes the most out of it
Ground | Time Period | Matches Played | Won batting first | Won batting second |
Motera,Ahmedabad | 2003-08 | 7 | 2 | 5 |
SMS, Jaipur | 2006-08 | 7 | 2 | 5 |
A couple of options come to my mind at this point which I think would make these games competitive.
Option1: Each team would play 50 0vers in two splits such that each split is at least for 15 overs. Also there is at least one power play of 5 overs in each split. A vs B goes some thing like this -
The team winning the toss would decide what they want to do and the team batting first say A would declare when they want to split, then team B bats and declares when they want to split so that the team A can continue their innings and complete it following which team B would chase the target.
Option 2: This one flows from the huge success of 20 cricket. A couple of innings of 20/25 overs each where the team winning toss would either choose to bat or bowl in the first innings and team losing toss would decide what they want to do in second innings.
The options sounds crazy is it - but let us wait and watch!!!